I recently purchased the Boyfriend Pillow The Original Boyfriend Body Pillow Blue from Amazon for a friend as a novelty gift and wasn't quite sure what to expect. Overall, I have been relatively pleased with this purchase, but it's not without its flaws.
The pillow is well made and comfortable - which is the primary purpose of purchasing one of these types of pillows in the first place - even coming complete with an extended arm like a virtual real man! The cotton fiber feather-free design also makes it more durable than some other gag or novelty gifts; something that won't fall apart after only a few uses like many others on the market today.
However, while this pillow felt comfortable when laying down on it initially, after lying down for longer periods of time it began to feel less so as my body temperature started to rise due to added warmth from being cuddled up into such an intimate form factor. In addition (even though it does come with an ultra soft cover,) I feel like over time covers wearing out may be difficult considering how snugly people tend to hug their pillows when sleeping at night!
Ultimately, if you're looking for something unique and cosy then I would recommend giving the Boyfriend Pillow The Original Boyfriend Body Pillow Blue from Amazon a try - just know that you might not get all night comfort out of it depending on your preferences!